More American families ditching expensive mortgages for renting (2024)

Families who have turned their backs on the struggle to own their own homes in the overheated property market say they have few regrets – even if it means being priced out forever.

The proportion of single-family homes being built for rent has doubled in two years as corporates eye up those who have had enough of paying a mortgage.

Analysts warn that the trend will only drive prices higher for those determined to buy, but the temptation to halve their housing costs and ditch the worries of ownership is proving hard to resist, with a third of all rentals now single-family homes.

Chelsey and Spencer Marks had just spent thousands of dollars on repairing the air-conditioning at their California home when they realized they would have to buy new windows and a replacement pump for the pool.

'I was like, I can't do this anymore,' Chelsey, 41, told the LA Times. 'One day I came home and I was like, 'We're selling the house'.'

Chelsey and Spencer Marks despaired at the cost of maintaining their three-bedroom house in Cathedral City, California, after spending $15,000 on air conditioning alone

The couple has wiped out their debt and improved their standard of living in a new rent-only subdivision 15 miles up the road at La Quinta

They moved 15 miles up the road from Cathedral City to SolTerra, a 131-home subdivision built solely for rent, wiping out their credit card debt, boosting their savings and allowing for an Italian vacation.

'I don't need to own it to be living that life that I want to live.'

Mortgage rates have doubled in the last three years and the US Federal Reserve announced on Wednesday that the base rate would stay at its 23-year high.

California's Legislative Analyst's Office calculates that monthly payments to buy a mid-tier home are up 80 percent since the start of the decade when taxes, maintenance and insurance are taken into account, making it twice as expensive to buy a two-bedroom home than to rent it.

Erick Carcelen, 47, realized he would pay $6,000 a month to buy his dream home before moving into a four-bedroom, three-bathroom rental in Menifee with his wife and three daughters.

'I'd rather pay $3,800 and be like, I'm freaking comfortable,' he said.

Corporate investors became seriously interested in the rental market after the credit crunch of 2008 and are now increasingly building entire rental estates according to Doug Ressler of commercial real estate firm Yardi Matrix.

'There's still an inadequate supply of housing, the cost of housing has continued to rise, renters are renting longer,' he said.

'The large providers are looking at build for rent as a legitimate strategy to be able to fulfill demand for those people that are on a budget and looking to have a larger square footage than an apartment.'

Erick Carcelen, 47, cut his monthly housing bills from $6,000 to $3,800 by moving with his wife and three daughters to a rental only development in Menifee

Now his family enjoys amenities including a lap pool, spa and clubhouse in a gated community

The 300-home estate was built solely for rental byTricon Residential, a development company bought for $3.5 billion last month by Blackstone, the world's biggest private equity firm

Developer Bill Shopoff of Shopoff Realty Investments built the SolTerra estate in La Quinta after realizing the huge untapped demand for larger rental homes.

He fitted out his three and four-bedroom homes with Spanish-style roofs, colorful mosaic tiles, private garages and state of the art appliances.

Tenants can get to know each other in the community pool, clubhouse and landscaped parks.

The estate opened last summer with rents ranging from $3,299 a month for a 1,520-square-foot home to $4,460 for those with 2,400 square feet.

'I'm not sure that if you didn't see the rental sign you'd be able to discern the difference,' he said. 'That's our intention. It lives and feels as if you were a homeowner.

California Assembly Member Christopher M Ward is drawing up legislation in a bid to restrain the new rental giants

'That looks like a hole in the market that we should be trying to solve.'

Some of the world's largest firms have smelled hefty profits in the distorted housing market and Blackstone, the world's biggest private equity fund, snapped up leading developer Tricorn Residential for $3.5 billion last month.

It built Carcelen's home alongside 300 others in Menifee and 170 in neighboring Wildomar, with plans afoot for another 493 in Winchester.

But critics have warned that the American dream of home ownership is becoming increasingly unobtainable for young families squeezed out of a market now geared to renting.

California Assembly Member Christopher M Ward is drawing up legislation in a bid to restrain the new rental giants, warning that corporate investors 'have a significant advantage over a typical California family'.

'You are allowing a new phenomenon in transactions that is inherently uncompetitive,' he added.

But Shopoff says corporate interest is increasing the number of homes being built and allowing people to realize an otherwise impossible lifestyle.

'It's interesting that government wants to restrict capital, but capital is only responding to the demand,' he added.

The proportion of single-family homes being built for rent is now at its highest since data started being collected in the 1970s but some renters are determined to return to home ownership.

Roofing contractor Deonte Palm is one of Carcelen's neighbors on the Menifee estate after moving from an apartment where 'we were feeling the walls closing in on us'.

'I was like, I can't do this anymore,' said Chelsey, 41. 'One day I came home and I was like, 'We're selling the house'.'

SolTerra opened last summer with rents ranging from $3,299 a month for a 1,520-square-foot home to $4,460 for those with 2,400 square feet

Tenants can get to know each other in the community pool, clubhouse and landscaped parks

The 30-year-old has now moved with his wife and new baby into a four-bedroom new build which they share with his brother, his girlfriend and their two-year-old.

The two families are happy to split the $3,400 rent between them while they wait for mortgage rates to come down.

'More space and saving money,' he said.

But Ressler warned that those moving into rental risk being permanently shut out of ownership.

'The rising costs of housing and mortgages is going to be around really for an extended period of time,' he added.

More American families ditching expensive mortgages for renting (2024)

FAQs

More American families ditching expensive mortgages for renting? ›

Americans are giving up their mortgages to 'rent forever' in larger homes with lower monthly costs - but experts warn of terrible downsides. Families who have turned their backs on the struggle to own their own homes in the overheated property market say they have few regrets – even if it means being priced out forever ...

What percentage of Americans are struggling to pay rent? ›

About 40% of households earning $45,000 to $74,999 were rent-burdened, and almost 70% of households between $30,000 and $44,999 were burdened. In 2022, 83% of low-income households were cost-burdened, with 65% experiencing severe burdens.

What percentage of Americans are homeowners vs renters? ›

What is the current homeownership rate in the U.S.? The national homeownership rate is 66%, which means that 66% of households own their home while 34% rent.

Is renting really cheaper than buying? ›

Nationwide, the typical home costs nearly 37 percent more to buy than to rent on a monthly basis. Rent increases have softened across the U.S. over the last year, and the combination of high home prices, elevated mortgage rates and low housing inventory creates a strong headwind for aspiring homeowners.

Why is owning a home more expensive than renting? ›

If you decide to rent over owning a property, then you are not required to pay (1) maintenance costs or repair costs, (2) no real estate taxes, (3) no down payment for the purchase of the property, and (4) no purchasing costs. Moreover, cities often have rent controls that keep the rents affordable.

What percentage of Americans can afford a home? ›

The survey found that 63% of Americans can't afford to buy a home this year, with 87% of Gen Z unable to and 62% of millennials unable to. Given the housing market, 1 in 4 surveyed no longer believe that homeownership is a good investment in the long run, and 1 in 3 don't believe it should still be the American dream.

Do more people rent during a recession? ›

So whether there's a real estate recession or a national economic recession, the demand for renting homes and apartments will rise in either scenario because people won't have the financial means to buy them.

What state has the highest percentage of renters? ›

Renters make up a much larger share of households in California (44%) than in the rest of the US (35%)—or in any state other than New York (46%), according to the US Census. This pattern predates the current surge in housing prices and has proved remarkably consistent over the last six decades.

What state has the highest homeownership rate? ›

In the rolling mountains, hills and valleys of Appalachia, you'll find the state with the highest percentage of homes occupied by their owners: West Virginia. The Mountain State has the highest homeownership rate in the entire country, at 74.5 percent, according to the latest Census Bureau data.

Do most Americans buy or rent? ›

65.8% of Americans own their homes outright. The homeownership rate was 3.8% points higher than the rate in the second quarter of 2019 and 2.6% points higher than the rate in the first quarter of 2020. Renter households earn a median of $41,515 in 2017 while homeowners earn a median of $77,523.

Is renting really throwing money away? ›

That's not true. In fact, the top-selling financial author of all-time, Robert Kiyosaki, says, “A home is a liability, not an asset.” An asset puts money into your pocket every month. A home takes money out of your pocket every month. Some say, “Paying rent is like throwing money away.” That's not true either.

Is it ever a good idea to rent? ›

While it is true that you aren't building equity in a property, renting does have its advantages, as mentioned above. Remember that your rent payments are giving you a roof over your head and you don't have to pay for maintenance costs either.

Is renting cheaper than buying in 2024? ›

Realtor.com's newly released monthly rental report found renting a starter home is a more affordable option than buying one in all 50 of the largest metropolitan areas in the country. “The monthly cost of buying a starter home in February 2024 was $1,027 more or 60.1% higher than the cost of renting,” the report read.

Why the rich are renting instead of buying? ›

Renting relieves you of paying for the maintenance, insurance, property taxes, and other costs of owning a home. If you're a high-net-worth individual who splits their time across different properties, you probably don't want to spend time dealing with the headaches that come with ownership.

Is it smarter to rent or buy? ›

Renting a home provides much more flexibility. However, if you have returned to the office, either full time or partially, and assume you'll remain in your current job for a few years, then buying a home might be wiser.

What are the cons of renting? ›

All the fees, none of the equity
  • Unable to enjoy tax deductions.
  • Your rent will most likely grow from year to year.
  • You're not building equity.
  • More difficult and expensive to have pets.

How many people in the US are rent burdened? ›

The center's analysis of 2022 census data found that 22.4 million renter households are burdened, with a record 12.1 million spending more than half their income on housing.

How many Americans are behind on rent? ›

One million California renters are behind on their rent payments, and almost 150,00 of them believe that it is very or somewhat likely they will face eviction in the next two months, according to recent Census Bureau surveys.

How many Americans can't afford housing? ›

The latest data from the Harvard Joint Center for Housing Studies, released in January, found that a record high 22.4 million renter households — or half of renters nationwide — were spending more than 30% of their income on rent in 2022.

What percent of Americans don't budget? ›

27% of Americans Don't Think They Need a Budget

Almost 30% of Americans don't budget because they simply don't think they need this tool. Men are slightly more likely than women to say they don't need a budget, but women are almost 4% more likely than men to say they won't stick to a budget.

Top Articles
Latest Posts
Article information

Author: Aracelis Kilback

Last Updated:

Views: 6073

Rating: 4.3 / 5 (64 voted)

Reviews: 87% of readers found this page helpful

Author information

Name: Aracelis Kilback

Birthday: 1994-11-22

Address: Apt. 895 30151 Green Plain, Lake Mariela, RI 98141

Phone: +5992291857476

Job: Legal Officer

Hobby: LARPing, role-playing games, Slacklining, Reading, Inline skating, Brazilian jiu-jitsu, Dance

Introduction: My name is Aracelis Kilback, I am a nice, gentle, agreeable, joyous, attractive, combative, gifted person who loves writing and wants to share my knowledge and understanding with you.